The Hike Was the Opening Act. The Dot Plot Was the Headliner.

Wednesday, September 16

The Federal Reserve raised its benchmark rate a quarter point Wednesday, to a target range of 3.75% to 4.00%. First increase since July 2023. The vote was 12 to 0, which, on a committee that spent July splitting 9 to 3, is less a consensus than a white flag.

Chair Kevin Warsh sanded no edges off it at the 1:30 CT press conference. "The plain fact is that inflation is too high and has been for too long," he said, and the move "will support a timelier return to the committee's 2 percent goal." He added that he does not believe the Fed needs "to do harm to the labor markets to achieve our objective," a sentence central bankers say shortly before the labor market is informed otherwise.

Then came the dot plot, the anonymous chart where each of the eighteen officials marks where rates ought to end up, like an office pool nobody has to sign. Twelve of the eighteen now pencil in one more quarter-point hike this year. Four want two. Two are done.

Here's the Thing: yesterday we said the dots were the story and the hike was the formality, and that is exactly how it broke. The hike was in the price. The staircase behind it was not. Sixteen of the eighteen people who set the cost of money in this country looked at the rate they had just voted for and wrote down, the same afternoon, that it is still too low.

Stocks did not break, which is the surprise. The S&P 500 ETF finished off 0.44%, a number that badly undersells a session spent more than 1% down at the lows before clawing back. The Nasdaq 100 ETF closed green, by 0.03%, which on a hawkish-hike day is the equity market whistling past the cemetery.

The Dow was the ugly one at -1.15%, and the reason has a name and a payroll. Goldman Sachs fell 3.96% after CEO David Solomon told a Barclays conference that fixed-income trading is running softer this quarter than equities, and that non-compensation expenses, meaning everything the firm spends that is not somebody's paycheck, will jump more than $500 million from last quarter. At $938 a share, Goldman is the Dow's highest-priced stock, and that index weights by share price rather than company size, so one bank's middling quarter moves it more than most of the real economy does. Financials fell 1.62% as a group. Banks are supposed to enjoy higher rates. They declined.

August retail sales landed five hours before the decision, and they were loud. Total retail and food services sales hit $773.9 billion, up 1.2% on the month against roughly 0.8% expected, and up 6.0% on the year. Strip out cars, and it was up 1.4%. July was revised down to -0.5%, so the American consumer took one month off and came back with a grudge.

Import prices rose 0.7% in August and 7.0% over twelve months, the biggest annual jump since the stretch ending August 2022. Import prices are what Americans pay foreign sellers before anything gets marked up at the register, so a 7% year is the tariff argument quietly settling itself inside a government spreadsheet instead of on cable news.

The Atlanta Fed's GDPNow, a growth estimate that rewrites itself whenever fresh data lands, jumped to 5.1% from 4.4% in a week.

Yesterday we made much of foreign buyers ghosting the 20-year auction. Treasury's July capital flows landed Wednesday and complicate that. Yes, a net $27.9 billion long-term outflow, but foreigners bought $40.6 billion of American paper, $44.4 billion of it by foreign official institutions. Americans bought $68.5 billion of everyone else's. That is US money leaving, not foreign money fleeing, and those are very different stories.

Housing, meanwhile, remains the one room not at the party: builder confidence fell to 32 from 35, and the MBA's weekly survey put the average 30-year mortgage quote at 6.97%.

Earnings: nothing you own. The slate is microcaps and foreign listings, which after Wednesday counts as mercy.

That noon TIPS auction. TIPS are Treasuries whose payout adjusts with inflation, so the yield they clear at is the real yield, what a buyer keeps after inflation takes its cut. If it clears cheap, meaning buyers wanted extra even with inflation protection bolted on, then a 10-year above 5% was never an inflation scare. It is the market repricing what America pays to borrow, and no amount of cheerful news about shoppers fixes that.

Sixteen of eighteen people just told you money gets more expensive from here. The Nasdaq closed green anyway, which is either conviction or a hearing problem.

Follow us on X and Instagram for daily market updates

Markets don't wait, and neither do we. Follow Tracking the Trade for fast takes, the numbers that matter, and the occasional meme that hits a little too close to your portfolio.

Nothing here is investment advice. We are a newsletter, not your fiduciary, and the only position we hold is that the market is funnier than it thinks it is. Do your own homework.